Tuesday, November 22, 2011

No Charge, small collection for wine, and postcards. Charming Event: 6 Gallery and the Public Debut of “Howl”

This, my third post, defines the terms "public" and "private" as they relate to the practice of exploring social discourse.  Similar to the film The Social Network, which many of my students have written about, I chose to explore the reading of Allen Ginsberg's poem "Howl."  When this work is explored beyond the page, it becomes quite clear much more was at stake than literary supremacy when these seminal words were uttered for the first time on a public stage.  At this moment, we bear witness to a monumental shift in the manner in which the writer, the word, and the culture shifted to recognize the marginalized as the voice of America.  

In 1952, Jack Kerouac listed the chief members of the [Beat] movement in a letter to Ginsberg, explaining that the crucial motivation for their union was the ability to  honestly confess each other their deepest feelings.  Such open revelation of private matters contradicted the spirit of the age, but led to aesthetic and intellectual discoveries.
On Friday, October 7, 1955, in a small art gallery that once functioned as an auto repair shop in San Francisco, Allen Ginsberg, along with Philip Lamantia, Mike McClure, Gary Snyder, and Phil Whalen, stepped out naked (as Ginsberg would later do literally at future events) to profess what Kerouac demanded years earlier.  
Richard Eberhart, in his New York Times article “West Coast Rhythms,” described the reading:
The highpoint of the evening was Ginsberg’s unveiling of his recently completed poem Howl which he delivered with such passion that the audience was electrified.  It wasn’t  simply the torrent of language, but the fact that Ginsberg was speaking on behalf of all of them, articulating their feelings of ‘lostness in modern America’... [it is] a howl against  everything in our mechanistic civilization which kills the spirit... Its positive force of energy comes from a redemptive quality of love, although it destructively catalogues evils of our time from physical deprivation to madness (Eberhart).  
With Kerouac in attendance --- the Dionysian source of wine and inspiration --- the young Ginsberg, high on drink himself, bolstered by an inebriated Kerouac’s chants of “Yes” and “Go,” slowly uttered for the first time publicly the eventual anthem of the Beat, Cold-War era counter culture : “I saw the best minds of my generation destroyed by madness.”  This act of pubic realization was no simple feat for Ginsberg as stated by McClure.  “At first, Ginsberg thought that “Howl” was too personal for publication, but he did begin revising it almost immediately, combining the short lines into expansive out-breaths, and dropping out more diffuse language.” Through "Howl," Ginsberg penned the American tale that spoke directly to the heart of both his literary contemporaries and the public masses - the men and women of the audience entrenched in the flawed American ideal - those individuals that longed for the space and ostensibly the voice they were said to attain through eventual reform.  His initial premonition that the piece was best left for private discussion is refuted by his revisions.  Taking a cue from old Jack, Ginsberg sought out to create a poem that defined a new American voice by extolling the very vernacular of the American.  The poem achieved a sense of the sublime through the poet’s voice - a sound or tone that was not lost in print, as the style, the chants, the call and response, seemingly begged for audience/reader participation.   
“Ginsberg knew he was at a crossroads in his art between apprenticeship to academic models of literature, and breaking through to a personal voice which could sing of experience beyond the bounds of what was permissible - by 50’s academic standards - to speak in poetry” (Silberman).  "Howl," written in a voice that displayed Whitman’s active participation, displays immediately through the opening lines Ginsberg’s perspective as a witness to the shortcomings of his generation.  The first verse, the portion of the text written and read that faithful evening (as the second and three verses were later added to the original text), talks directly to those characters that the Beats identified with, and society marginalized.  The “angelheaded hipsters,” Ginsberg’s audience and muse, became the poetic identity of the downtrodden - America’s artists, addicts, and outcasts. 
And as these first poignant lines were spoken, the Beat Generation’s communal identity of literary misfit-vanguards was lost to the public they sought to resurrect.  Kenneth Rexroth, the events master of ceremonies, compared the burgeoning San Francisco artistic community to an anarchist movement that flourished culturally despite the oppression that existed throughout the majority of the nation (Schumcher).   
 The Changing Face of America: Consumerism, Homogeny, and the Burgeoning Middle Class
Confusion, an identity crisis of sorts, defined America during the post war society of the 1950s.  As the war came to a close, class structure shifted, not in terms of a reshuffling of previous participants, but rather in a blurring of the definitions that constituted social status, in terms of economic and social capital.  As Americans reaped the benefits of a new found consumer identity, they saw themselves living as members of a new middle class, a working middle class. The suburban worker at this time commanded salaries that allowed for increased spending in the field of consumable goods, such as automobiles, kitchen appliances, and a plethora of mass-produced items, that in years past signified wealth reminiscent of true middle / upper class status. 
The very items that vaulted these members of society into an elevated class status would eventually prove to be the material goods that forced compliance to social and economic restrictions placed on the whole by the whole.  In other words, the human desire to prosper, to consume, to attain individual wealth was met with a cost.  Once a fair share was obtained of the desired allotment of goods, the consumer became tethered to these items.  The working middle class became extensions of corporate conglomerates, acting as spokespeople for the items they owned, and the items that defined their identity.  In essence, the working class saw this as upward mobility; what actually transpired was a fixing of social hegemony. 
Under the watchful eye of corporate America, the working class grew, and as their buying power increased, so did the goods marketed by powerful advertisement agencies. What was left of the working class was a social group designed to consume in order to maintain a new social position that itself maintained a ceiling, and consequently lacked any true worth.  Simply stated, these men and women remained workers for the upper class and, at the same time, becoming consumers who returned their wages on Saturday to the very corporations that paid them on Friday.
The perpetual cycle of the disillusioned working class accepting oppression remains evident throughout this period.  The only difference being that the oppression became more comfortable to bear and less obvious as it was hidden behind the single family homes of suburbia.  It seems that man, having all that he could conceivably desire, saw his demise just moments after tasting the forbidden fruit offered by the oppressive factions of society.  Tytell writes, “The postwar era was a time of extraordinary insecurity, of profound powerlessness as far as individual effort was concerned, when personal responsibility was being abdicated in favor of corporate largeness, when the catchwords were coordination and adjustment, as if we had defeated the Germans only to become “good Germans” ourselves” (5). 
Private Ruminations for Public Consumption 
The ideal or norm of American society exists in its ability to dictate experiences.  A stagnant life offers little in terms of experience as it, by its very definition, asks the participant to settle into a pattern - a pattern of economics, class, theology, race, and overarching identity.  For the Beats, ideas such as the road, manifest destiny, and democracy acted in an antithetical manner.  The desire to rest idle in terms of private thought was replaced by a sense of hyper-realization --- an unrelenting need for experience, to shape and shift, and shape and shift again and again --- calling the writer to express publicly what had previously only been fodder for those comrades worthy of breaching the seal of the scribbled reflective thoughts of the reclusive poet.  The axiom is this: motion, in the public sphere inspires; rest, in the private recesses of seclusion, allows the writer the ability to access and reestablish a public voice/identity. 
Fleet of foot, mind, and soul, the writer moves freely, as he/she is not bound by the laws of society - the oppressive forces of normalcy.  Rather, perpetual motion from the private to the public spheres allows the individual the unique ability to write in response to the cultural immediacy of the time.  For the Beats, to simply analyze social injustice form the safety of their homes, their journals, would only serve to strengthen existing forms of oppression.  Rather, these writers saw the public forum as a space to incite conflict through an irreverent display of self-actualization.   As stated by Joseph Harris, “a public space is one where the members of various communities can meet to negotiate their differences.  It is a site of conflict rather than consensus, of bartering rather than sharing” (109).  And for the Beats, this public discourse was designed to expose the flaws of poetry and general public dialogue concerning the arts.  “The desire to remove the literary superego was a sign of how the Beats would struggle with the conditioning influences of language; in many ways it represented a fulfillment of the romantic credo as formulated in the Lyrical Ballads in which Coleridge and Wordsworth promised to use language of ordinary men” (Tytell 17).  In terms of public discourse, the Beats saw language as an act of unity.  In other words, if language existed as it had in the past - those affected by social injustice would be left isolated/fragmented by the immense nature of both the oppressor and the inability to define, in common terms, the subjective nature of 1950s / 1960s American society.  
Ginsberg directly addressed this literary shift in his 1966 Paris Review interview:
 ... what happens if you make a distinction between what you tell your friends and what you tell your Muse? The problem is to breakdown that distinction: when you approach the Muse to talk as frankly as you would take with your friends. So I began finding, in  conversations with Burroughs and Kerouac and Gregory Corso, in conversations with people whom I knew well, whose souls I respected, that the things we were telling each other for real were different from what was already in literature. And that was Kerouac’s great discovery in On The Road... And the hypocrisy of literature has been - you know like there’s supposed to be a formal literature, which is supposed to be different from... in subject, in direction and even organization, from our quotidian inspired lives. 
According to Richard Eberhart’s article “West Coast Rhythms,” “Ambiguity is despised, irony is considered weakness, the poem as a system of connotations is thrown in favor of long-line denotative statements. Explicit cognition is enjoined. Rhyme is outlawed. Whitman is the only god worthy of emulation.”  The language of Kerouac and Ginsberg - the long lines of Whitman that they held in such high regard, were designed to push the reader forward, calling on the willful participant to survey what binds them socially by understanding that these structures only exist, with the exception of natural law, to stagnate our understanding of the very hegemonic structures that negate investigation of control.  
The Beat movement was a crystallization of a discontent with American ‘virtues’ of progress and power... The romantic militancy of the Beats found its roots in American transcendentalism. Their spiritual ancestors were men like Thoreau with his aggressive  idealism, his essentially conservative distrust of machines and industry, his desire to return to the origins of man’s relations to the land; or Melville, optimistically proclaiming with egalitarian gusto the raw newness and velocity of self-renewing change in America while joyously admiring the potential of the common man (Tytell 4). 
For the reader, writer, and student of the text, it is paramount to realize that seminal Beat works such as Ginsberg’s “Howl”, Kerouac’s On the Road, and Burrough’s Naked Lunch pierce ideology by grounding the soul in natural democracy, natural language while adhering to the ever present call for modern individual equality as evidenced in the trials that were to follow for both Ginsberg and Burroughs - the question of whether the constitution was drafted with these men and their words in mind. 
Regina Marla writes in her text, Queer Beats, it is quite evident that these men --- through the composite of central literary, social, and economic themes --- understood the present state of American social affairs and chose to respond, attempting to restructure class and find a place for the stagnant male in poetry and prose that spoke of the common man by writers who longed to --- like Whitman earlier --- destroy prevailing social attitudes through an immense output of literary and social commentary that celebrated the average man and American democracy (9).  Therefore, the public writer, speaking colloquially with his fellow man, acted to counter what Ginsberg described as the “syndrome of shutdown” - a move toward a closed society where all decisions would be secret.  “In the fifties... the Beats discovered a natural counter for the silence of the day in a new sense of self, a renaissance of the romantic impulse to combat unbelievably superior forces.  The Beats crashed through the restraining mask of the removed artist - the tradition that saw the artist as God, omnipresent but invisible...” (Tytell 16).
The Public Reaction: Dada Aesthetics in Beat Presentation
The song of the open road --- the Beat response to homogeny through fluidity --- adapts to the traveler and the period, and is exemplified by the desire to make public what was in years past left to private ruminations.  If the norm is defined by its binary abnormal, then Beat writing and its ideals inverted the process by juxtaposing these writers’ thoughts with stringent social norms - redefining normalcy through the perspective of the abnormal social participant by advancing an agenda in accordance to acceptable social practices. In other words, writers such as Kerouac, Ginsberg, Burroughs, Corso and an endless array of additional participants took their opportunities, their cue, from the practices of the norm.
The Beats were attracted to "madness" as a sustained presence; a lucid, singular, and obsessive way to illuminate the shadows of the day. Was William Blake, for example, acting madly when he read Paradise Lost with his wife while both sat naked in their garden? ... So long as Blake remained naked in the privacy of his garden, he was merely eccentric.  But like the European Surrealists [Dadaists], the Beats wanted their Blake to dance naked in the public garden, and this was interpreted as a threat to public dignity (Tytell 11).  As the theater of World War II came to a close, in a manner similar to that of WWI, Beat writers seemingly mimicked their Dada predecessors.  Dada looked to the carnage of war as fodder that would provide the new public “show” of a modern existence.   Man, standing on the precipice of uncertainty, was exposed to the unfiltered mind of the Dadaist --- one that called for “Shock Art” to revel in the chaos by presenting art’s ambiguities.  “Dada was born from what it hated.  At first it was commonly thought to be an artistic and literary movement or a mal du siecle.  But Dada was the sickness of the world” (Hugnet and Scolari 3).  Members of the movement saw art as a means of revolution and protest against the traditional, prevailing order of society that understood war to be a viable solution to conflict.  Exhibited in any public forum, Dadaists questioned the validity of nationalism or a collective identity that marginalized those working from the periphery.  
The public display of what was deemed anti-art by dadaists --- a retort to the failed state of political, economic, religious, and most specifically the arts --- was not lost on the young Ginsberg.  As the poem concludes, Ginsberg speaks directly to the movement, stating: “who threw potato salad at CCNY lecturers on Dadaism/ and subsequently presented themselves on the/ granite steps of the madhouse with shaven heads and harlequin speech of suicide, demanding/ instantaneous lobotomy,” calling for the academy to reevaluate the manner in which education was provided post war.  In this case, the student’s understanding of the harsh realities of the world far exceeded any lesson a professor could provide.  To discuss Dada as an academic endeavor, through academic analysis, was an act of heresy.  The academy, according to Ginsberg, was no longer a place for normalcy - the private discussion of knowledge for the institution by the institution. Rather, the academy was to become a place of discontent - the din of competing voices that gathered not to praise what once was, but instead debate for what was to come.  
Fillmore Street San Francisco: All are Invited 
Although far less perverse than the Dada instillations of post WWI Europe, the general sentiment to incite public response reverberated in the communal space that was to become the evening Allen Ginsberg stepped out from behind the Beat identity of New York’s angelic, poetic hoodlums, and found the agency to speak publicly on matters that resonated with him as an individual in the context of social discourse.
Seemingly out of the gutters of New York City, the Beat Generation’s move from private to public was in all actuality a process that required Ginsberg to flourish intellectually through a growing comfort with his own abilities as a writer.  In private, Ginsberg, working along side fellow men of the same ilk forged ahead through discourse to come to some understanding of how the individual moves from communal negotiation to the larger context of social discourse while walking a paradoxical tightrope.  Steve Silberman, in his article “How Beat Happened,” discusses the romantic identity that only added to the Beat lure.  “Though one prevalent myth is that the Beats were a lone wake-up call in ‘50s America, that summons did not come from nowhere.  Laying the intellectual foundation for the Beats breakthrough, The Rexroth circle was a ground of opposition: well-read and international, homosexual, and heterosexual, poets and artists from several generations of revolt” (Silberman).  In this sense, the writers of the Rexroth circle worked to present the agreed upon objectives of the whole while maintaining the constructed self that these writers aspired to exist as in public. Through debate in private discourse communities, consensus, in terms of risk versus reward was realized.  Therefore, the public identity of the writer, Ginsberg as it were, was forged as a response to previous private negotiations and the subsequent implications of moving said dialogue to a public space. 

The identity that best expounds the essence of the Beats, through Ginsberg’s nascent quest by way of the recited poem, is the writer as the pure realization of the society from which he was created.  Nothing was to be left unsaid.  The taboos of addiction, homosexuality, and madness must be terms prominently displayed for renegotiation.  In other words, through the act of publicly redefining these terms, the very source of their original status as forms of oppression was negated.  Art was to be an act of private inquiry left for public consumption.  As Tytell writes, “... nakedness did not exist simply as an aesthetic standard, it was to become a public and private stance...” (4).  Ginsberg’s work “Howl,” his desire to stand alone and speak to the ills of his time, demanded the very country that betrayed his freedom become instantly aware of the artist as a figure of reform.  Standing alone, “blowing” as Kerouac would have stated, was the act of the sole writer laying claim to the moment of presentation as an act of self-actualization - the public act of rebirth so as to recover identity.     

No comments:

Post a Comment